Best Homeowners Insurance in Illinois – Guide

A house insurance policy may give comfort of mind and the protection you need to feel safe and protected, from unintentional fires destroying your home’s structure to burglars taking your personal things.

The This Old House Reviews team investigated the best homeowners insurance companies in Illinois and discovered that American Family, State Farm, and Lemonade are the best options. Read on to evaluate each company’s coverage options, cost, and perks.

When you’re ready for a policy quotation, call 855-948-5219 or input your ZIP code into the simple widget below.

How to Find the Best Illinois Home Insurance

People seeking for the finest house insurance in Illinois should select a policy that strikes a balance between pricing, service reputation, and financial stability.

While MoneyGeek compiled this data for you, you may also investigate for yourself to better assess your alternatives.

Investigate Illinois Customer Service Reputations

In this tutorial, MoneyGeek examined the customer service reputations of several insurance.

You may, however, seek for J.D. Power satisfaction rankings and NAIC complaint percentages in Illinois for insurers you’re interested in researching.

The website of the Illinois Division of Insurance is also useful.

Compare Your Own Quotes

While MoneyGeek investigated average house insurance quotes for a typical driver, it’s recommended to acquire at least three quotes and compare prices for yourself, as the most suitable policy for you will depend on your profile and past.

Check if the company in Illinois provides the coverage you want

The main insurers promote certain coverages or reductions in a variety of places, but such benefits aren’t always accessible in every state.

Always confirm with insurance providers in Illinois that they provide the coverage you require.

Check Financial Stability Ratings twice

It is critical to verify an insurer’s financial strength rating since a company’s financial state might impact the resolution of your claims. Large insurance firms are often financially stronger.

Homeowners Insurance Coverage in Illinois

In Illinois, homeowners insurance plans often include the following coverage types:


This kind of coverage is intended to restore or rebuild your home if it is damaged by a covered risk.

For example, if a covered natural catastrophe destroys your home’s structure, your insurer will pay the cost of rebuilding it up to an agreed-upon maximum, which is normally equal to the property’s estimated worth and replacement cost.

Other constructions

This policy, like dwelling coverage, repairs or rebuilds buildings that aren’t considered part of your house, like as a fence or shed.

This coverage typically has limits of roughly 10% of the overall dwelling coverage amount.

Personal Responsibility

If someone is hurt on your property and you are found to be at fault, personal liability insurance will cover their medical expenses and legal fees if they decide to sue you.

Other People’s Medical Expenses

Medical payments will be made by your insurance for injuries sustained on your belongings that are not your fault. This type of insurance typically covers between $1,000 and $2,500 in costs.

Personal Belongings

You can choose coverage for your personal possessions’ actual cash value (ACV) or replacement cash value (RCV), ensuring that your home insurance carrier will pay for either the depreciated worth of what you own or the substitute cost for the ones that are new.

Loss of Utility

This coverage pays for any additional living expenses incurred if you are displaced from your home due to a covered risk.

For example, if a fire renders your home unusable, you may be required to stay in a hotel paid for by your service provider.

Other expenditures, such as petrol from an extended commute or extra food, may also be covered by this coverage.

Considerations Before Purchasing Homeowners Insurance

Before acquiring a house insurance coverage, consider the following points.

House Worth

Have an appraiser come out to your property and determine its value so you know precisely how much home insurance you need to restore the structure if it is damaged in an unforeseen disaster.

Added Protection

If you’ve got a pool in the back yard, you should consider additional liability coverage in case of an unforeseen pool-related event.

Furthermore, if you’re concerned about harm from sewage or drain backups, you should consider purchasing optional water setback coverage, which is available from most agencies.

Common Reductions

Searching for discounts is an excellent method to save money on your insurance rate. When collecting estimates from multiple firms, compare the discounts they give to see where you can save the most money.

For example, if you already have vehicle insurance, inquire with your provider about house and auto packages.


A bigger deductible might help you reduce your rate. Keep in mind, however, that increasing your deductible might be more expensive in the long run if you need to submit a claim.

What is the average cost for homeowners insurance in Illinois?

Compare the best Illinois homeowners insurance carriers.

In Illinois, the average cost of homeowners insurance is $1,410 per year for $250,000 in dwelling coverage, or about $117 per month. This corresponds to the national average of $1,428 per year.

Final Post Wrap

We suggest American Family for its comprehensive coverage, State Farm for its list of advertising, and Lemonade for its innovative technology features and purpose-driven giveback program for the best homes insurance in Illinois.

We recommend receiving quotes from all three companies in this review before signing up for a policy to compare prices in your location.

Fill out this simple online form, phone 855-948-5219, or use the tool below to obtain a free quotation.

Leave a Comment